"After Luke," which references the book in the Bible containing the prodigal son legend, draws on sibling rivalry as well as generational combat. Half-brothers Maneen and Son have been at each other's throats since boyhood—"Like a bag of cats," comments their father. The faithful, somewhat dull Son has remained with his widowed Dadda in Cork while the younger Maneen sought his fortune in London. Now that local property values have soared, Maneen is back with an eye to selling the place. Naturally, Son doesn't want to give up his home, and the fight over property becomes a duel for Dadda's affection. Each brother believes the other is the favorite, and Dadda is caught between them. "I treated youse differently, but in an equal sort of way," their father explains. Alternating between monologues and scenes, Gregg and Mellamphy endow Son and Maneen with equal doses of pettiness and tenderness. Colin Lane expresses Dadda's internal conflict with agonizing specificity. You can see he loves both sons but hates the havoc caused when they get together.
"When I Was God" is almost as effective as "Luke," except that the staging is static in places, and Creedon's poetic repetitions could use cutting. The framework is a soccer match, the last one for a retiring referee who recalls his painful childhood with a brutish father demanding he excel at sports. Much of the play finds Gregg as the father stationary on top of a small platform, with Mellamphy, doubling as the referee and his own mother, scampering about at stage level. Creedon has written some hilarious dialogue—the father ranting about the importance of winning at all costs and the son fantasizing about taking a trophy—but too many of the scenes cover the same territory, even employing the same lines. Despite these flaws, "God" is an entertaining two-hander match, and the entire evening is a touching, heartbreaking look at fathers and sons.
Presented by and at the Irish Repertory Theatre,
132 W. 22nd St., NYC.
Aug. 6–Sept. 27. Wed.–Sat., 8 p.m.; Wed., Sat., and Sun., 3 p.m.(212) 727-2737.