The first half of Artifacts of Consequence has the charm of a suspenseful science-fiction novel as we become engrossed in unraveling what we're watching. But Halfnight keeps adding to it, much like Dallas' obsessive collecting, until what was a lean, ambiguous story becomes a bloated, ponderous ode to pop culture. Even as Halfnight's heartbreaking ending is happening, there's the lurking suspicion that nothing preceding it has earned such a powerful finale.
Director Kristjan Thor coaxes fine performances from the actors, but the writing's lack of depth is a major obstacle. Buffamanti giggles and deadpans with flair as the painfully innocent Ari, but there's nothing to her but pop-culture references and strange sexual fantasies about interloper Theo (Marty Keiser). Keiser, at least, doesn't have to embody an archetype and seems to thoroughly enjoy himself. And while both Lingafelter, who has a mean throwing arm when it comes to Twinkies, and McCarty sink their teeth into juicier roles, they're defeated by their characters' utter lack of common sense. As a cultural artifact, file Consequence somewhere between a pet rock and disco.
Presented by Electric Pear Productions and Performance Lab 115
at the Wild Project, 195 E. Third St., NYC.
April 21–May 2. Mon.–Sat., 8 p.m.
(212) 351-3101, (866) 811-4111, wwwtheatermania.com, or www.electricpear.org.