How to Get Cast on ‘Crystal Lake’

Article Image
Photo Source: Matt Infante/PEACOCK

We’ve been dying to see Peacock’s prequel to the “Friday the 13th” franchise, “Crystal Lake,” ever since the streamer announced the project back on Halloween 2022. For a while, it looked like the series might not survive development. But it’s proven to be as resilient as Jason Voorhees himself. Now, years after its straight-to-series order, a mid-development showrunner swap—Brad Caleb Kane (“Welcome to Derry”) took over for Bryan Fuller (“Hannibal”) in August 2024—and a storyline redirect, A24’s “Crystal Lake” airs on the NBC streamer starting Oct. 15, 2026. But what does it take to land a role in a horror series like “Crystal Lake”? It’s sink or swim in the audition room, so our survival guide features everything you need to know about the casting process.

JUMP TO

What is “Crystal Lake” about?

“Crystal Lake” is a prequel to the original “Friday the 13th” (1980), which was directed by Sean S. Cunningham. That film, produced after the success of John Carpenter’s “Halloween” (1978), follows a group of teenage counselors refurbishing Camp Crystal Lake, where a young boy named Jason Voorhees tragically drowned years earlier. One by one, the counselors are killed off, and the murderer is revealed to be (spoiler alert!) Jason’s mother, Pamela Voorhees (Betsy Palmer).

“Friday the 13th” was a surprise hit, grossing nearly $40 million domestically on a $650,000 budget and spawning 11 more films. Steve Miner’s “Friday the 13th Part 2” (1981) made Jason the killer, and “Friday the 13th Part III” (1982) gave him the hockey mask that would become his trademark. Over the decades, Jason has macheted his way through countless victims, been hacked apart and resurrected multiple times, fought fellow slasher icon Freddy Krueger, and gone to New York City, outer space, and hell.

In “Crystal Lake,” however, we learn Pamela’s origin story. The series will explore how the grief-stricken mother ultimately became a murderer with a dark past of her own. Pamela grows close to the town’s chief of police, Levon Brooks, but as their friendship evolves, bodies begin to pile up, leading the officer to investigate the increasingly suspicious events unfolding in Crystal Lake. Can Pamela uncover what really happened to her son while clinging to the hope that he might still be alive? 

Of course, “Crystal Lake” isn’t the first time the franchise has tried its hand at television. From 1987 to 1990, “Friday the 13th: The Series” aired 72 episodes; the show focused on an antiques dealer who sells cursed goods (thanks to a lucrative deal with the devil, no less). When the dealer dies—his punishment for rebelling against the devil—his niece and her cousin inherit the shop and his underworldly responsibility. (No, we’re not sure what this had to do with the Jason Voorhees saga, either.)

Who is in the cast of “Crystal Lake”?

Peacock’s “Crystal Lake” stars:

  • Linda Cardellini as Pamela Voorhees
  • Gwendolyn Sundstrom as Grace Snell
  • Danielle Kotch as Claudette
  • Phoenix Parnevik as Barry
  • Daniel Stewart Sherman as Enos
  • Bernadette Quigley as Trudy
  • Joy Suprano as Rita
  • Callum Vinson as Jason Voorhees (child)
  • Zachary Branch as Jason Voorhees (adult)
  • William Catlett as Levon Brooks
  • Devin Kessler as Brianna Brooks
  • Cameron Scoggins as Dorf
  • Brian J. Carter as John Christy
  • Nancy Nagrant as Kay Christy
  • Jud Meyers as Harry
  • Drew Scheid as Shutterbug
  • Christopher Denham as Dr. Theodore Landau
  • Manon Gage as Harmony
  • Dan Thompson as Steve Christy
  • Albert DiCesare as Space Ghost
  • Philip Themio Stoddard as Gabe

We also know “Crystal Lake” will welcome back the franchise’s original final girl: Adrienne King, who played sole survivor Alice Hardy in “Friday the 13th.” Fans will recall that Alice didn’t survive “Part 2,” thanks to an ice pick to the head from Jason. But since “Crystal Lake” is a prequel series—and debuts more than four decades after King’s first appearance in the franchise, no less—it’s safe to assume she isn’t reprising her original role.

Crystal Lake

Who is the casting director for “Crystal Lake”?

According to the show’s production list, Margery Simkin (“Little Shop of Horrors”) and Orly Sitowitz (“Them That Follow”) were the primary CDs behind “Crystal Lake,” with Grant Wilfley (“The Bride!”) casting extras and background actors.   

As Simkin told us, doing good work remains the best way to stand out in an ever-evolving industry. “Everybody wants the magic bullet and the answer. If I said, ‘You’ll stand out if you wear a blue shirt,’ then suddenly everybody’s gonna wear a blue shirt, and they won’t stand out. There isn’t one way to do it. You have to be true to yourself,” she shared. “When people try to be something else to make it work, they do everyone a disservice—themselves and those of us assessing.” 

Crystal Lake

How does the casting process work for “Crystal Lake”?

While Cardellini is no stranger to the horror genre—“The Curse of La Llorona” instantly comes to mind—her costar and onscreen love interest, Catlett, didn’t watch Cardellini’s previous work before heading into the chemistry read, opting to play off his first impression instead. 

“I knew some of Linda’s work, but I don't like to really research other actors when I know that I’m going to read with them,” Catlett told the crowd at a New York Comic Con sneak peek, according to GoldDerby. “I just looked at a picture of her online and said, ‘Ooh, I can fall in love with that woman.’ ”

For the children who play Jason (Vinson) and Grace (Sundstrom), the audition process was quite secretive. Cast under the code name “Mama’s Boy,” they weren’t aware of the series’ true nature right away. 

“I only found out that it was ‘Friday the 13th’ by, like, the third callback,” Sundstrom told the audience. “I was just really interested when I first read the lines, and I immediately fell in love with Grace.”

Meanwhile, Vinson was excited to finally have a reason to binge the films. “I have watched [all the films] up to ‘Part VI,’ ” he shared. “I’ve loved Jason ever since I was a kid. I wanted to watch [the movies] for so long, and I finally booked this, and I was like, ‘I can finally watch this!’ ”Research is important when you’re playing such an iconic character, after all!

Crystal Lake

Where can you find “Crystal Lake” casting calls and auditions?

As a limited prequel series, there are no plans to renew “Crystal Lake” for a second season. This roundup of horror gigs, however, might satisfy your thirst for something scary. You might also find our guide on how to get cast on “Poker Face” helpful—it offers insight into the casting process behind one of Peacock’s top TV shows.   

Of course, there’s no harm in bookmarking our main casting page, which regularly updates as new opportunities become available. If you have your heart set on landing a role on a show like “Crystal Lake,” we also recommend getting an agent if you don’t have representation already, since industry insiders often have access to calls that aren’t made public. 

More From How to Get Cast On

Recommended

More From Actors + Performers

Now Trending