Understanding Union Rules for Actors in ‘Right-to-Work’ States

Article Image
Photo Source: Joel Filipe/Unsplash

Are you an actor who lives in a right-to-work state? Or are you an actor wondering what a right-to-work state is in the first place? Here’s everything you need to know about how actors’ unions like SAG-AFTRA or Actors’ Equity operate in states with union prevention laws. 

Throughout their history, unions have often incited controversy. Although modern work culture has benefited from labor activism (like weekends, holiday breaks, and overtime pay), those advances were earned through hard-fought political campaigning, coordination, and conflict. 

In recent years, labor activism in the United States has seen a rise. The United Auto Workers held a 40-day strike against General Motors over contracts for temporary workers in 2019. In the past two years, teacher strikes from West Virginia to Oklahoma have drawn attention to the power of organized striking. 

State legislatures have attempted to curb union activism and power through policies known as “right-to-work” laws. So, how do these laws impact actors? Here’s what you should know.


What is a “right-to-work” state?

The phrase “right-to-work” is itself controversial because it’s crafted with political spin. Coined by lawmakers and strategists, the phrase is designed to suggest that unions oppose the right to work. Although the term has caught on, some unions have attempted to rebrand the laws as “right-to-work-for-less” policies. So, for now, let’s just call the policies union prevention laws. 

Congressional attempts to make union prevention laws country-wide have failed, so states have modified the labor laws within their jurisdiction. This means the laws vary from state-to-state. 

States without union prevention laws require workers in a unionized workplace to pay dues to the body, as pertinent negotiations benefit all employees. This requirement means that because the union is negotiating for worker benefits, all workers must compensate the union—whether they want to or not. Workplaces in these states are known as “closed shops,” which means that to be hired in a unionized workplace, you must be a union member. For an actor, this means getting a gig in on a unionized production can result in automatic union membership. It might also mean that union actors are prioritized in the audition process. 

States with union prevention laws, however, do not mandate employees to pay a fee to a union. This intentional loophole means that even if a union negotiates for worker benefits, the workers don’t need to join the union. Workplaces in these states are known as “open shops,” which means one doesn’t have to be a union member to be hired in a unionized workplace. For an actor, this means that if you’re hired at a unionized theater, you have a choice whether to sign a union contract or not. 

These policies influence the degree that labor unions can organize and gain momentum in certain states:

  • In states without union prevention laws, some unions have built-in constituencies and revenue streams. 
  • In states with union prevention laws, it’s hard for unions to recruit members when workers could benefit from a union’s activism without having to contribute to the cause. Without recruitment, the union lacks a workplace majority and funding. 

The major employment markets for actors (California, Illinois, and New York) do not have union prevention laws (i.e., they’re not in “right-to-work” states). However, actor unions fight against such laws in solidarity with the labor movement at-large. 

Why does union prevention legislation exist?

Some argue that “right-to-work” policies support small businesses and allow workers to advocate for themselves on an individual basis. However, others say that these policies are designed to crush union power in certain states to the benefit of big businesses. 


What should union actors know if they live in a right-to-work state?

“A state’s standing as to so-called ‘right-to-work’ does not directly impact a union member,” says Rodger Brand, a member of SAG-AFTRA’s national board and chair of the union’s Right-to-Work Committee. “Members working in ‘right-to-work’ states still enjoy all of the rights and privileges of membership;” these include involvement in union elections, awards, and educational opportunities. 

“However, members are still obligated to abide by all of the union’s membership rules,” Brand continues. “Including Global Rule One,” which states that union members cannot work nonunion gigs. “Members also know that by agreeing to work only union, they maintain professional standards and rates of pay,” he says. “Without this strength, it would be a race to the bottom.”

Are actor unions lobbying in states that are not union-friendly?

“Members are often engaged regionally in activities to organize new employers, fight for fair treatment or better working conditions, and encourage legislative activity to improve the lives of their fellow performers,” Brand says. Recently, SAG-AFTRA has campaigned for regulating child labor, fighting ageism, promoting image rights, and protecting state and local tax incentives for the entertainment industry. However, the union has seen the most legislative traction in the state houses of New York and California. 

In 2017, Actors’ Equity Association launched its Equity 2020 campaign—with sizable membership approval—designed to increase regional activism outside of its major three cities of New York City, L.A., and Chicago. Since, the union has rebooted its online resources and has hired high-profile legal counsel to pump up the union’s national sway. 

“It’s a perilous time for unions,” Equity president Kate Shindle told Backstage. “There’s ‘right-to-work’ legislation being proposed all over the country which would essentially starve unions of funds, and it is a large-scale way of weakening unions and, by doing that, weakening workers and transferring more power to management and corporations.” 

What are the states with union prevention laws?

So-called “right-to-work” states include Alabama, Arizona, Arkansas, Florida, Georgia, Idaho, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Michigan, Mississippi, Nebraska, Nevada, North Carolina, North Dakota, Oklahoma, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Virginia, West Virginia, Wisconsin, and Wyoming. In these states, there are union prevention laws on the books. 

Why would politicians oppose unions in the first place?

Typically, union activism leans in the direction of liberal policies. Historically, unions have supported Democratic politicians, providing a reliable source of votes for blue candidates. However, that is not always the case. Police unions around the country have unflinchingly supported Republican President Donald Trump. Also, it’s worth noting that, before he was president of the country, Republican Ronald Reagan was president of SAG. All to say, if you disagree with a union’s politics, you might dislike the organization as a whole. 

Sometimes politicians get large-scale campaign donations from wealthy business owners who don’t want their workers to unionize. If a politician relies on donations to campaign victoriously, they will support legislation that nods to their benefactors. Unions also give to political campaigns, which could position them against certain rivals. 

“There’s ‘right-to-work’ legislation being proposed all over the country which would essentially starve unions of funds, and it is a large-scale way of weakening unions and, by doing that, weakening workers and transferring more power to management and corporations.”

Kate Shindle

President, Actors’ Equity

Some unions have built a reputation for corruption. For example, the UAW has been subject to a long term federal corruption probe; recently a top official in the union pled guilty to financial misconduct. Martin Scorsese’s Oscar-nominated Netflix film of 2019, “The Irishman,” is about the notorious labor figure of the teamsters, Frank Sheeran, who allegedly had ties to the mafia and confessed to murdering Teamster’s union president Jimmy Hoffa. Robert De Niro plays Sheeran and Al Pacino plays Hoffa. 

Finally, sometimes unions have considerable infighting and toxicity. SAG-AFTRA has become notorious for warring factions of competing slates. In the most recent leadership election, a death threat against the incumbent SAG-AFTRA president was retweeted by an opposing party in the union. Internal conflicts can be used to delegitimize a union’s common cause and its members. 

Does anti-union legislation only impact actors who live in “right-to-work” states?

When it comes to anti-union legislation, union leaders encourage vigilance and engagement from professional actors whether they live in a “right-to-work” state or not. “Without sounding dramatic about it, I think we are all very aware that the right to be a union member, the right to organize and bargain together for fair wages and working conditions is not a foregone conclusion,” Shindle said to Backstage. “We will have to fight for our survival.”

Keep up to date with all things union right here on Backstage.