How to Get Cast on ‘The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel’

Article Image
Photo Source: Nicole Rivelli

Amazon’s hit Emmy-winning series “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel” is now casting for Season 5. For those interested in acting on the show, read this in-depth guide that covers everything you need to know about the audition process and beyond. From the types of roles production is currently looking to fill to helpful tips from the show’s casting directors, let this be your go-to resource. 



What is “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel” about?

The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel is a comedy-drama series about a 1950s Jewish housewife, Miriam “Midge” Maisel (Rachel Brosnahan), who is driven to try a career in standup after her husband, Joel (Michael Zegen), abruptly leaves her for his secretary. The show also follows Midge’s relationship with her parents (Tony Shalhoub and Marin Hinkle) and Joel on New York City’s Upper West Side, as well as her growing partnership with her manager, Susie Myerson (Alex Borstein). Season 4, which premieres on Amazon on Feb. 18, is expected to follow Midge as she continues to balance her family life with her comedy career. 

Amy Sherman-Palladino, the mastermind behind “Gilmore Girls” and “Bunheads,” created “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel.” She’s also the showrunner and an executive producer. The pilot was filmed in New York City back in late 2016 and early 2017. The show premiered on Amazon Prime in March 2017, with the series earning a pickup shortly after.

Is “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel” currently filming?

While Amazon has not officially announced Season 5 of “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel,” we have confirmation that a new season is in the works. Per our sources, production is set to begin in late February. Notably, Amazon confirmed Season 4 of the series just one week after Season 3 premiered—so it wouldn’t be surprising if that’s also the streamer’s strategy this time around. 

Taxi cab on set

Where can you find “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel” auditions and casting calls?

As of now, “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel” is actively casting on Backstage for various background actors, aged 18 and older, for Season 5. According to the casting call, filming will take place in the New York City area between February and June of this year. COVID-19 testing and costume fittings in New York are required. Pay is $182 for eight hours of work, along with a $100 testing stipend. Actors looking for other gigs that are similar to the hit Amazon series can check out these related projects that are also hiring. 

Meeting at a diner

Who is in the cast of “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel”?

The show’s cast includes: 

  • Rachel Brosnahan as Midge Maisel
  • Alex Borstein as Susie Myerson
  • Tony Shalhoub as Abe Weissman
  • Marin Hinkle as Rose Weissman
  • Michael Zegen as Joel Maisel
  • Kevin Pollak as Moishe Maisel
  • Caroline Aaron as Shirley Maisel
  • Luke Kirby as Lenny Bruce
  • Bailey De Young as Imogene Cleary
  • Joel Johnstone as Archie Cleary
  • Matilda Szydagis as Zelda
  • Cynthia Darlow as Mrs. Moskowitz
  • Brian Tarantina as Jackie
  • Jane Lynch as Sophie Lennon
  • Zachary Levi as Benjamin Ettenberg
  • LeRoy McClain as Shy Baldwin
  • Stephanie Hsu as Mei

Emmy-nominated actor Jackie Hoffman (“Feud,” “Birdman,” “Garden State”) and Allison Guinn (“Boardwalk Empire,” “Inside Amy Schumer”) will have recurring guest roles on Season 4, per Deadline. And according to TVLine, Milo Ventimiglia (“This Is Us”), who previously worked with Sherman-Palladino on “Gilmore Girls,” will guest star on Season 4—and may even be a potential new love interest for Midge. 

Group at an amusement park

Who is the casting director for “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel”?

Season 1 of “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel” was cast by Jeanie Bacharach, Meredith Tucker, and Cindy Tolan. Tolan then worked solo on Seasons 2, 3, and 4. Tolan’s previous experience includes casting “If Beale Street Could Talk,” Steven Spielberg’s “West Side Story,” “Straight Outta Compton,” “Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt,” and “The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks.” 

Though Brosnahan has cemented herself as an iconic casting choice, things could have looked a lot different for the Amazon series. While Bacharach told Backstage that she “actually thought of Rachel when I read the script,” Sherman-Palladino and writer-executive producer Dan Palladino didn’t care about finding a big name—and that meant auditions. “Amy and Dan’s writing is so particular that they weren’t comfortable making an offer [without an audition],” Bacharach explained. Brosnahan auditioned late in the process, but the CD knew she was the obvious choice for the role. “The concern was that Rachel didn’t have a lot of comedy experience,” Bacharach said. “But when she read [Midge’s] big, drunken monologue, which was part of the audition process for ‘Mrs. Maisel,’ she nailed it in a way that other people had not found.”

Bacharach also envisioned Borstein in the role of Susie from the start, but “Amy had originally seen Susie and Midge as the same age or closer in age.” Still, after seeing actors who fit the character breakdown, the creators decided to go with Bacharach’s instinct. “[Borstein] can break your heart. Her ability to be vulnerable was, I think, important for Susie’s overall journey,” said Bacharach. “She wasn’t just this wiseass, tough lady, but had sacrificed things in her own life to be where she is, for better or for worse.” 

When Borstein auditioned, it was clear to the CD that she was the right fit for Susie. “She read with Rachel, and magic was born,” Bacharach recalled. “Usually, you think of chemistry reads as being for love interests, but their chemistry was very important, and it was pretty apparent from the get-go.”

Tolan talked with Awards Daily about what it was like to work with Sherman-Palladino, given that her dialogue has a very particular rhythm to it. “My associate and I call it ‘The Palladino Pace.’ When we are in auditions, everyone comes in, [and] they try it their way first. If they need an adjustment, we give it to them—and oftentimes, it’s the pacing of it,” Tolan explained. “It’s a nice way to see if the actor can pick it up and not stumble over their words. That’s why I say it’s all about language skills, because it’s so deceptive. It doesn’t need to just be fast; you need to be able to hit what you are saying and understand it in order to land the joke.”

Mrs. Maisel walking down a hallway

What are the best audition tips for landing a role in “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel”?

Ready to audition for Season 5? Check out these audition tips from the show’s creator, writer, and casting directors to make sure you come prepared.

  1. Think long-term. “Make the most of every audition, whether it be for a project like ‘Maisel’ or not. Be prepared, do the homework going into the room, and think about going into that audition to win the room and not the role. Only one person can get the job, but a CD isn’t only ever casting just that role; they’re casting parts they don’t even know exist yet. Trust that if you’ve done great work, the CD is going to remember you for other things.” —Jeanie Bacharach, casting director
  2. Accept that you won’t be right for every part. “I will sit there and I will work with actors, but…you as an actor cannot be everything. You cannot twist yourself into a pretzel and say, ‘But I could have been this.’ There are so many factors that go into casting that the actor is not privy to. The actor just has to feel good about what they did in the room and then leave it in the room.” —Cindy Tolan, casting director 
  3. Sometimes, it pays to be a little cocky. “We were extremely intrigued, because [Brosnahan] didn’t have any comedy on her résumé. To say, ‘I’m going to play not just a comedic part, but a comedian’—that takes a lot of hubris, which we like, and a lot of confidence. And that’s how she came in.” —Daniel Palladino, writer–executive producer
  4. Collaboration is key. “We will not offer it to anyone [without an audition]. We have to know that it’s going to be a collaboration. It’s setting someone up to fail if they’re not in a good work environment. This is not an audition as in: ‘You’re good; you’re bad.’ It’s: ‘How are we going to take this journey together?’ ” —Amy Sherman-Palladino, creator

Check out Backstage’s TV audition listings!